Will iBooks Author Actually Reduce the Cost of Producing Textbooks?

If you've been following tech blogs these past few days then you've probably heard about iBooks Author. This is Apple's new digital textbook creation tool, and if you believe the hype it's going to reduce the cost producing digital textbooks. I'm not so sure it will, and even if it does the savings won't be as big as you might think. (Please feel free to prove me wrong.)

The thing that some seem to have missed about iBooks Author is that it is an assembly tool, not a creation tool. It's designed to make it easy to pull together the parts of a digital textbook into  whole. It lowers the skill level required, and that is a good thing.

But it doesn't actually help you make the parts. You can embed video and audio, but first you have to produce them. You can add a 3D model, but first someone has to program it. And of course you can have text and pictures, but first they have to be written and edited.

The only way I could convince myself that there were savings was if I ignored the significant cost of producing the components. For example, take the sample textbooks that you can currently download for free from iBooks. I've downloaded none of them due to the size; they're all 1GB or more. But that size tells me that they're all chock full of video, models, and other snazzy content which was not cheap to produce. iBooks Author could have saved how much, exactly? Whatever it is, I bet the savings are actually less than any single production cost.

BTW, I know the costs of  particular textbook project. Back in December I posted about a trio of high school teachers who wrote their own textbook. They took parts of an existing CC licensed stats textbooks and wrote the parts they needed. They had to change it so it met MN state standards, covered the necessary core requirements, and used examples that their students would understand. Their total cost to produce the textbook was round $25,000.Most of that went to pay the teachers' salaries for the time they spent writing. Would iBooks Author really have reduced the cost any?

Now, I will grant you that iBooks Author will help in the final stages of making a digital textbook, but I do not see how it can help the overall production cost. You cannot even use it to organize the project, much less make any of the parts.

Would someone care to prove me wrong?

About Nate Hoffelder (11479 Articles)
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader: "I've been into reading ebooks since forever, but I only got my first ereader in July 2007. Everything quickly spiraled out of control from there. Before I started this blog in January 2010 I covered ebooks, ebook readers, and digital publishing for about 2 years as a part of MobileRead Forums. It's a great community, and being a member is a joy. But I thought I could make something out of how I covered the news for MobileRead, so I started this blog."

3 Comments on Will iBooks Author Actually Reduce the Cost of Producing Textbooks?

  1. Overall, the costs go up

    But it depends on whose perspective you adopt:

    The additional cost associated with of content creation falls on the author of the textbook (teachers, who in most cases have little ability to influence the format selected).

    The additional cost of the expensive hardware (Ipad) required to read the textbook falls on the student (who has NO say on the format selected). Or the school district (which has little influence on the format availability of nation-wide textbooks).

    The cost savings on printing, layout and assembly fall on the publisher (who has the largest vote with regards to format selection).

    • Okay, that is the best summary I’ve ever seen for who likes this app and who Apple was pitching to. Thanks!

      • But if the pitch is to publishers (rather than authors) isn’t that ignoring two elephants in the room?

        1. Amazon
        2. iPad only is a huge limitation especially since it includes no iPhone (and no Mac). Apple could change this, of course, but they’ve shown little to no desire to do so.

        What good is saving a few pennies on printing, layout and assembly if you reduce your addressable audience by a factor of 10 or more?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.