launches Australian ebookstore where you can’t download your purchases

by Chris Walters

It begins! The ebooks-in-the-cloud concept that I warned against earlier this week, the one publishers say is the ideal future marketplace (for them, not for consumers), is in private beta right now in Australia.

It’s using the Monocle web-based ebook reader–which I find really awesome, to tell the truth–and partnering with Readings, a small Australian book chain, to sell ebooks to Australian customers. It looks great. It’s the future of ebook sales. And it stinks.

I really don’t have any complaints about Monocle, except that I caught a couple of bugs during my brief testing of the interface on the Readings website. As far as making it easy to read an ebook online, Monocle works great, and it’s compatible across a wide variety of devices. You can try it out for yourself on the site.

The small detail that ruins everything, though, is that when you buy an ebook from Readings/, you never get to download the file to your computer or device. It’s stored permanently with the retailer, then called up and displayed to you whenever you request it. To head off customer complaints, takes advantage of HTML5?s ability to store offline files in your browser, so in general it’s possible to read your purchases even if you’re not online.

But you’re never given the option to download a file of the ebook, even a file with DRM. Here is how puts it on their “about” page:

Can I download ebook files to read in another app? – In, an ebook is a web link – we believe books are part of the web, in much the same way as a YouTube video is part of the web. It’s always there when you want it, but you don’t “download” anything.

I’ll give them points for copywriting–that sure sounds like a perfectly reasonable and forward-thinking approach, when it’s put that way!–but it doesn’t change the fact that is basically telling you, “We keep full control of your purchases, so suck it.” You will never be able to do anything with your ebook that doesn’t approve of first.

No matter how nice the Monocle interface looks, it fills me with loathing. It’s the most anti-consumer approach to ebook retailing yet, and you can bet it’s going to spread to other retailers in the coming years if enough consumers don’t push back.


  1. yuzutea20 January, 2011

    I would only be ok with this if the books cost radically less than downloadable ebooks.

  2. Mireya20 January, 2011

    Unless they actually sell their ebooks at lower prices than $2, I would never consider anything like this.

  3. Quasar20 January, 2011

    I figured this is how google ebooks would work. And in theory I’m fine with it. Just that I’d want it from an org that I have trust will be around for a long time.

    Actually I think something like this would be nice for libraries.

  4. Luqman21 January, 2011

    As far as libraries are concerned, how is it any different from netlibrary, which has been around for quite some time?

  5. Moriah Jovan21 January, 2011

    I don’t know if regular Kobo is like this, but with the Kobo BlackBerry app, I have to be connected to read my books.

    To say I’m peeved is a bit of an understatement.

  6. Mags24 January, 2011

    Moriah, is there a “download to device” button on the books when you read on the Kobo BlackBerry app? I have it for webOS, and I can download the book. I have to be connected to do so, of course, but I always do it so I can keep reading if I lose my 3G.

  7. Re Readings, Bookish and other people who love ebooks « Overland literary journal13 February, 2011

    […] one of the Readings ebooks. But this is what I found most interesting: Thing is, I’m not a cloud hater. Google’s new ebook service is built upon a similar premise, and Google ‘do no evil’ right?. […]

  8. […] covered it  several times, but I first heard about just over a year ago. One of the early demos of the reading app […]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top