Editor’s Note: Before you read this post, be aware that this web page is sharing your usage with Google, Facebook, StatCounter, several ad networks, Quantcast, and Harlequin.com. Google because of the ads and Google+ button, Facebook because there’s a “Like” button, StatCounter because I use it to measure usage, and Harlequin because I embedded the cover for Rebecca Avery’sdirectly from Harlequin’s website. Harlequin’s web server has been sent the address of this page along with you IP address as part of the HTTP transaction that fetches the image, which, to be clear, is not a picture of me.
I’m pretty sure that having read the first paragraph, you’re now able to give informed consent if I try to sell you a book and constitute myself as a book service for the purposes of a New Jersey “Reader Privacy Act”, currently awaiting Governor Christie’s signature. That act would make it unlawful to share information about your book use (borrowing, downloading, buying, reading, etc.) with a third party, in the absence of a court order to do so. That’s good for your reading privacy, but a real problem for almost anyone running a commercial “book service”.
Let’s use Maid Crave as an example. When you click on the link, your browser first sends a request to Harlequin.com. Using the instructions in the returned HTML, it then sends requests to a bunch of web servers to build the web page, complete with images, reviews and buy links. Here’s the list of hosts contacted as my browser builds that page:
- seal.verisign.com (A security company)
- www.goodreads.com (The review comes from GoodReads. They’re owned by Amazon.)
- seal.websecurity.norton.com (Another security company)
- stats.g.doubleclick.net (Doubleclick is an advertising network owned by Google)
- cdn.gigya.com (Gigya’s Consumer Identity Management platform helps businesses identify consumers across any device, achieve a single customer view by collecting and consolidating profile and activity data, and tap into first-party data to reach customers with more personalized marketing messaging.)
- www.facebook.com (I’m told this is a social network)
- fbstatic-a.akamaihd.net (Akamai is here helping to distribute facebook content)
- platform.twitter.com (yet another social network)
- edge.quantserve.com (QuantCast is an “audience research and behavioural advertising company”)
All of these servers are given my IP address and the URL of the Harlequin page that I’m viewing. All of these companies except Verisign, Norton and Akamai also set tracking cookies that enable them to connect my browsing of the Harlequin site with my activity all over the web. The Guardian has a nice overview of these companies that track your use of the web. Most of them exist to better target ads at you. So don’t be surprised if, once you’ve visited Harlequin, Amazon tries to sell you romance novels.
Certainly Harlequin qualifies as a commercial book service under the New Jersey law. And certainly Harlequin is giving personal information (IP addresses are personal information under the law) to a bunch of private entities without a court order. And most certainly it is doing so without informed consent. So its website is doing things that will be unlawful under the New Jersey law.
But it’s not alone. Almost any online bookseller uses services like those used by Harlequin. Even Amazon, which is pretty much self contained, has to send your personal information to Ingram to fulfill many of the book orders sent to it. Under the New Jersey law, it appears that Amazon will need to get your informed consent to have Ingram send you a book. And really, do I care? Does this improve my reading privacy?
The companies that can ignore this law are Apple, Target, Walmart and the like. Book services are exempt if they derive less than 2% of their US consumer revenue from books. So yay Apple.
Lord knows we need some basic rules about privacy of our reading behavior. But I think the New Jersey law does a lousy job of dealing with the realities of today’s internet. I wonder if we’ll ever start a real discussion about what and when things should be private on the web.
reposted with permission from Go to Hellman