Visual Editions Wants to Reinvent the eBook

Visual Editions Wants to Reinvent the eBook Enhanced eBook Google It's that time again.

Every couple years some outsider comes up with the brilliant idea of reinventing ebooks. If it's not Vook, it's Atavist. If it's not Inkling, it's Colliloquy. If it's not Byliner, it's Atavist. And if it's not Atavist, just wait 15 minutes and I'm sure another startup will be launched.

This time around the reinventor is London-based Visual Editions, which wants to "reimagine what the ebook can be from the ground up". VE announced in April that:

The realm of making digital books that are as playful and immersive as printed books are, is something we’ve been thinking about for a little while now. And we’re ridiculously excited to tell you, at long last, about our latest project Editions at Play, working with Universal Everything and Google’s Creative Lab to create a new space for digital books that couldn’t possibly live in print.

Visual Editions Wants to Reinvent the eBook Enhanced eBook Google Visual Edition plans to work with Google to launch a new part of the Google Play Store called Editions at Play. It's expected to launch sometime this fall, and will be "a place to showcase, celebrate, and bring out digital books that are immersive and were written and developed with the idea of being digital".

They don't have anything to show yet, but they are talking about their goals in lofty terms like their hope that "Editions at Play will have a URL that transports readers to a digital location or even into the real world (well why not?), or chase you across the internet; we imagine digital literature that has no beginning or no end, or landscapes that can travel in any direction or have any number of characters, plots, side plots and inventions".

In short, Visual Editions has discovered the idea of enhanced ebooks, and they plan to fling all sorts of ideas at the wall and see what sticks.

From what I have read VE hasn't proposed anything that could be called a new idea; it's all been done before in either enhanced ebooks, apps, websites, games, ebook apps, or some combination thereof, only now the ideas are being flung in the name of improving ebooks.

Sigh. Why do so many outsiders think that ebooks are a broken or incomplete art form?

I am all for someone developing a new way to tell stories; this has led to better story-telling in games and other media. But what I don't understand is why people keep insisting that their new art form has to replace ebooks.

It's not just that I like ebooks the way they are, but also that every past effort to reinvent them has failed utterly for the simple reason that readers don't want something different. They want ebooks as they are.

You can't fix what isn't broken, and yet so many people keep trying.

Okay, you can actually do that, but it requires genius on the level of Steve Jobs or Jeff Bezos (surrounded by a lot of other really smart people), and judging by their user-unfriendly and visually ugly website it is clear that the folks at Visual Editions aren't that smart.

But hey, at least the new attempt will have a pretty logo. (It's an animated Gif, which by itself is enough to tell you where this project is headed.)

Nate Hoffelder

View posts by Nate Hoffelder
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader: He's here to chew bubble gum and fix broken websites, and he is all out of bubble gum. He has been blogging about indie authors since 2010 while learning new tech skills at the drop of a hat. He fixes author sites, and shares what he learns on The Digital Reader's blog. In his spare time, he fosters dogs for A Forever Home, a local rescue group.

32 Comments

  1. neuse river sailor6 July, 2015

    Looking forward to clapping my hands and giggling like a three year old while I read my ebook about the economics of European post war steel consolidations.

    Reply
  2. puzzled6 July, 2015

    “Sigh. Why do so many outsiders think that ebooks are a broken or incomplete art form?”

    Because the odd ebook they read (a year) when they don’t have connectivity of some kind (in flight, beond the black stump, etc), just lies there and has no interactivity, and they get a brain fart and convince themselves that they’ve discovered something that no one else has.

    “But hey, at least the new attempt will have a pretty logo. (It’s an animated Gif, which by itself is enough to tell you where this project is headed.)”

    Yeah, nowhere. The logo just circles itself…

    Reply
  3. Gary6 July, 2015

    I am certain that sooner or later a new form of multi-media storytelling will be developed that uses digital technology to tell stories in new ways; ways that can only be achieved with digital technology.

    What I don’t understand is why the people who are trying to develop these new ways of telling stories would want to lock themselves into a mental straight jacket before they start by calling their product an “enhanced ebook” and by trying to sell their products to people who like to read traditional books. In my opinion, people who prefer to read a book are NOT likely to be interested in the new features they are trying to program into their storytelling.

    All of the wonderful new features that they talk about seem to me to be more related to TV or movie special effects, so why don’t they call it an “enhanced movie” or an “enhanced TV program”? Or why not come up with a distinct and original new name for a new art form?

    Reply
    1. fjtorres6 July, 2015

      Actually, somebody has already invented a “new form of storytelling” based on digital technology: the video game industry. Games like KOTOR, JADE EMPIRE, BIOSHOCK, MASS EFFECT, HALO, and many others all tell stories where you are the protagonist and you get the live the story. Some even let you mold the story so that no two “readers” experience quite the same story.

      The reason enhanced ebooks fail to take off is because the people interested in that kind of multimedia narrative are already getting it.

      Reply
      1. Nate Hoffelder6 July, 2015

        Yes.

        See, that’s one of the other things I don’t get about all these reinventors. Most of what they want to do has already been done in other industries; why try to recreate it in the book industry where it’s not wanted?

        Reply
        1. fjtorres6 July, 2015

          Because there are venture capitalists waiting to be fleeced?
          I also forgot to mention the story games from TELLTALE GAMES, like THE WOLF AMONG US, based on Bill Willingham’s FABLES.
          80% story 20% game = 100% fun.

          Reply
          1. Nate Hoffelder6 July, 2015

            And press willing to write about it.

            Reply
  4. fabrizio venerandi7 July, 2015

    Well, we started building ebooks in 2010. In five years we have seen “new way to read ebook” aka “the future of digital reading” aka “the future of book” more or less every month. Meanwhile we created ePub2 with non linear reading (from ebook game to hypertext literature), ebook updating themself, EPUB3 in media overlay, jukebooks for create ePub on the fly and more and more… But in on-line world we need “something new” to be shared for some hours.

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

      How many of those features do you use in the ebooks you publish?

      Reply
      1. fabrizio venerandi8 July, 2015

        “those features”. Are you referring to the “non linear reading, ebook updating themself, EPUB3 in media overlay…” et ceterae?

        Reply
  5. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

    You were typing too fast, methinks. Turn your spellchecker on.
    And of it’s not Atavist […]
    You meant ‘if’.
    […] every past effort tp reinvent them […]
    You meant ‘to’.

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

      That’s weird. I have a spellchecker, and it usually catches details like that. It didn’t this time.

      Thanks.

      Reply
      1. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

        You’re welcome. Because I’m Autistic I often see little things like that, and I can be nitpicky about them (YMMV).

        Reply
        1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

          Me too, it’s just writers can’t see that about their own work right away. It usually takes a few hours before we can see the flaws. And last night I crashed early.

          Reply
  6. Tajador7 July, 2015

    I’ve been waiting for years for the ebook to mark the glorious return of the Choose Your Own Adventure novel. Come on guys. It makes so much sense.

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

      That has actually been done a few times now. Colliloquy tried it as Kindle apps and went nowhere, and I think true CYOA books are now available digitally.

      I don’t think they’re in Epub, though.

      Reply
      1. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

        Nate, the problem with those books is the publisher seems to believe that iOS is the only OS ever developed for smartphones. They’ve completely ignored the existence of Android and Winblows Phone, and I had to contact them about these egregious omissions.

        Reply
    2. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

      I’m actually trying to do that, but although I can make the necessary XHTML and CSS files for the epub, I have no way to put them together on my Android devices and the only PC I have access to doesn’t allow me to create zip files with no way for me to install the necessary software.

      Reply
    3. fabrizio venerandi8 July, 2015

      Well, we did this, if you understand italian language.

      Reply
  7. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

    What? You’re also Autistic or you’re also nitpicky? 😉
    BTW, no need to explain. I had already figured that the errors occurred because that type of thing sometimes happens when one is human, and even on a good day I can make mistakes. 🙂

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

      Aspie, actually.

      Reply
  8. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

    Same difference, Autistic Spectrum = Autistic. The real difference is between Aspie and Autie, and even then there’s more similarities than differences. 🙂

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder7 July, 2015

      I know aspie is on the spectrum now, yes. I was endeavoring to be more specific.

      Reply
      1. Sheogorath7 July, 2015

        Technically, Aspies have always been on the Spectrum, but it’s only fairly recently (1994) that you’ve been recognised as such. I apologise for misunderstanding your intention anyway, and thank you for your clarification.

        Reply
        1. Nate Hoffelder4 February, 2016

          Er, no. The term Autism Spectrum was only invented with one of the recent revisions to the DSM, after which Asperger’s was listed in the same category as autism and several other neurological disorders.

          Reply
  9. […] print foundations for what it ambitiously imagines as the next generation in digital book content. Some, however, are skeptical that Editions at Play is much more than the latest chapter in the lackluster history of enhanced […]

    Reply
  10. Google ???????????????8 February, 2016

    […] ???????Visual Editions ?????? 2010 ??????????????????????????? Google ?????? 7 ?????????????????????? […]

    Reply
  11. […] The Digital Reader, a proposito di Visual Editions, Nate Hoffelder scriveva già nell’estate del 2015 che le aspirazioni della società londinese si sarebbero […]

    Reply
  12. […] print book designers Visual Editions announced their new collaboration with Google last year, they said that Editions at Play would "reimagine what the ebook can be from the ground […]

    Reply
  13. […] a little over a year now Google has been working with London-based print book designers Visual Editions to develop […]

    Reply
  14. […] this year the book design firm Visual Editions launched a new program to "reinvent the book". This program, Editions At Play, was developed in partnership with Google, and so far it consists […]

    Reply
  15. […] a little under two years now Google has been working with print design firm Visual Editions to develop new ways to tell […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top