eBook Subscription Services Are Legal in France

eBook Subscription Services Are Legal in France Streaming eBooks Subscriptions If you've been following digital publishing news over the past 6 months then you probably know that in late December French regulators expressed doubts that subscription ebook services were legal under France's fixed price book laws. Those doubts solidified into a legal opinion in February 2015 when Laurence Engel, la Médiatrice du livre, ruled that all the existing services were illegal under the letter of the law.

Kindle Unlimited and its local competitors Izneo, Youscribe, and Youboox were given five months to bring their services into compliance with the legal decision. I don't have news yet on Kindle Unlimited but I can report that Youboox, Izneo, and Youscribe are either now legal in France, or will be soon.

The three services had made proposals to Engel which were accepted, and they will be legal once they've changed their practices to match the proposals. They have six months to comply.

Izneo's solution was relatively straightforward: they pulled any digital comic titles not published by MP Group ( about 1% of the 1,500 titles offered via subscription). This move made Izneo's service legal by effectively granting the MP Group control. French law requires that the publisher control the price, and as the only publisher in that particular subscription service MP Group controls the price by default.

In related news, Izneo's retail store boasts 12,000 digital comic titles from over 60 different publishers.

I'm having trouble parsing the details being discussed in the source articles on Youboox and Youscribe, but I can report that my source says both services are legal. Youboox affirms that it will continue to charge a flat 10 euro per month fee.

We are still waiting to learn the steps Amazon will take to make Kindle Unlimited legal in France, and the same goes for Scribd.

Stay tuned.

IDBoox, IDBoox, IDBoox

Nate Hoffelder

View posts by Nate Hoffelder
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader: He's here to chew bubble gum and fix broken websites, and he is all out of bubble gum. He has been blogging about indie authors since 2010 while learning new tech skills at the drop of a hat. He fixes author sites, and shares what he learns on The Digital Reader's blog. In his spare time, he fosters dogs for A Forever Home, a local rescue group.

12 Comments

  1. fjtorres17 June, 2015

    I suspect it won’t matter.
    It’ll be illegal no matter what they propose.
    Just a wild guess. 🙂

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder17 June, 2015

      Heh. I was just thinking that.

      Reply
      1. fjtorres17 June, 2015

        Simple logic: subscription services don’t sell books.
        The subscriber receives no property rights.
        So if the service isn’t selling books, why invoke book pricing laws?
        But since they did…

        Reply
        1. Nate Hoffelder17 June, 2015

          See, there’s your mistake. You tried to apply logic to the law and to book publishing.

          You knew thta wasn’t going to work, right?

          Reply
  2. AC de Fombelle18 June, 2015

    Well, they can’t have it both ways, can they? eBooks aren’t considered as books when it comes to VAT (there is a special low VAT for books in France, it doesn’t apply to ebooks) so how can they be considered as books when it comes to fixed price book law?

    Reply
    1. LCNR18 June, 2015

      Actually, the reduced VAT rate does apply to e-books in France. However, this has been ruled to be illegal by the CJEU, though I understand that the European Commission is considering amending the VAT directive in that regard and that contravening countries are dragging their feet so that they do not have to undo legislation that might not be illegal anymore in the near future.

      The dichotomy (e-book/p-book pricing v. VAT rates) lies in the fact that VAT is a EU remit (VAT directive) whereas book pricing rules are subject to national legislation.

      Reply
  3. eBook Subscription Legal in France. Metadata Good For Book Sales TeleRead: News and views on e-books, libraries, publishing and related topics18 June, 2015

    […] eBook Subscription Services Are Legal in France (Ink, Bits & Pixels) Kindle Unlimited and its local competitors Izneo, Youscribe, and Youboox were given five months to bring their services into compliance with the legal decision. I don’t have news yet on Kindle Unlimited but I can report that Youboox, Izneo, and Youscribe are either now legal in France, or will be soon. […]

    Reply
  4. LCNR18 June, 2015

    If I understand correctly, in the case of Youboox, publishers will basically set a price per page for each book. Therefore, I suppose that by maintaining the 9.99 € fee Youboox figures (or hopes) that the average monthly page-views cost per customer will remain below that threshold. If not, it might have to change its formula, e.g., by creating a premium offer for heavy readers.

    Source: https://www.actualitte.com/article/lecture-numerique/la-mediatrice-du-livre-valide-les-modeles-d-offre-d-abonnement-illimites-d-ebooks/59028

    Reply
    1. Nate Hoffelder18 June, 2015

      Thank you for the details, and for pointing me at that article. I follow Actualitte but that hadn’t crossed my desk yet this morning.

      Reply
  5. […] Ebook Subscription Services Adjust to French Law (Ink, Bits & Pixels) Several of the leading ebook subscription services in France—excluding Amazon’s Kindle Unlimited, about which no word on the matter has yet been reported—are said to have adjusted their models to bring them in line with a recent ruling requiring publishers to maintain control over the prices of their ebooks, including on subscription platforms. […]

    Reply
  6. Eric19 June, 2015

    Hello All,

    I am the co-founder of http://www.cyberlibris.com, the oldest firm on that you all can eat subscription / streaming model (since 2001) in France. If you need first-hand info on what’s going on, I can help 🙂 Here is a link to a piece I recently wrote on subscription http://www.thebookseller.com/futurebook/part-1-ku-or-ko-streaming-subscription-and-big-data , Best, Eric

    Reply
  7. […] page; Scribd began a major rationalisation of the number of romance titles in its catalogue; and a legal ruling in France required all ebook subscription platforms to drop the ‘all you can ea… that defines them elsewhere around the […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top