Ellora’s Cave Sues Dear Author Book Blog for Defamation

3293465641_b6c5081e87_b[1]Here's something crazy. Romance publisher Ellora's Cave has been having financial issues for the past year or so, but rather than sit down and fix them this publisher has decided that the best solution was a public and messy defamation lawsuit.

Court documents filed today in Ohio have revealed that Ellora's Cave has filed suit against the author and blogger known as Jane Litte, the proprietor of one of the best romance book blogs.

Ellora's Cave alleges that a recent blog post on Dear Author defamed them, and in addition to suing the publisher also asks for a temporary restraining order - meaning that Dear Author might not be allowed to report that they are being sued.

Dear Author has been writing about Ellora's Cave for many years now (more details here),but according to the filing this lawsuit focuses on just the one post published earlier this month.

In "The Curious Case of Ellora's Cave", Jane detailed the rise and fall of this pioneering erotic romance publisher, including discussing the many current financial issues. For example:

Yet something strange happened. Growth stagnated. In 2010, it was revealed that EC’s revenues were $5 million but a reported $6.7 million in 2006. How on earth was a digital publisher’s income declining in the biggest boom period of digital books? (This was before self publishing took off).

Word of Ms. Engler’s increasingly erratic behavior surfaced on odd places on the internet and then came the lawsuits. In 2008, former employee Christina Brashears filed suit for unpaid monies against EC. EC countersued. Brashears, Publisher and Chief Operating Officer, left and formed Samhain. Bad blood existed which culminated with EC agreeing to a settlement of undisclosed amount. The damages were alleged to be in the high six figures to low seven figures. EC’s behavior during this lawsuit was so egregious, the judge commented on it in his ruling ordering damages to be paid to Brashears. In 2009, EC filed suit against Borders accusing them of illegal business practices. The suit went nowhere.

And:

What’s the result? Many people believe that EC will close its doors before the summer is over but at least by the end of the year. If it enters bankruptcy, author’s intellectual property rights are part of the estate and can be sold off to the highest bidder.  It could wind down and revert the rights back but it’s doubtful that will happen.

The lawsuit was only filed today, but Jane has indicated that she will fight this suit. She's looking for a good attorney in the Akron, OH, area with experience in defamation.

***

While I am not going to make a claim as to whether defamation occurred, I do want to introduce to an acronym which may be new to you: SLAPP.

SLAPP is short for "strategic lawsuit against public participation". This term was coined to describe a certain type of bogus lawsuit which is sometimes used by malevolent individuals to silence their critics. For example, if a publisher wanted to silence a blogger who had been airing said publisher's dirty laundry, they could file a SLAPP.

The cost of defending against a lawsuit can be onerous, leading some to give in. On the other hand, this type of lawsuit can also result in a Streisand effect, attracting even more attention to the story which Ellora's Cave is trying to bury.

What's more, even if this lawsuit doesn't generate even more negative publicity for Ellora's Cave, it will result in the public airing of all of that publisher's dirty laundry during the discovery process. If even half of the rumors going around are true, we could well see many authors suing Ellora's Cave for unpaid royalties.

image  by steakpinball

About Nate Hoffelder (11374 Articles)
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader: "I've been into reading ebooks since forever, but I only got my first ereader in July 2007. Everything quickly spiraled out of control from there. Before I started this blog in January 2010 I covered ebooks, ebook readers, and digital publishing for about 2 years as a part of MobileRead Forums. It's a great community, and being a member is a joy. But I thought I could make something out of how I covered the news for MobileRead, so I started this blog."

35 Comments on Ellora’s Cave Sues Dear Author Book Blog for Defamation

  1. I’m not sure what they are trying to accomplish here. Even if they gag Dear Author that really isn’t there biggest problem. Their own authors are out there blogging about not getting paid and saying alot of the things DA posted. Those authors are just getting louder not quieter. They are just going to draw more attention to themselves by doing this and I can’t see where any of it is going to be good or helpful to them.

  2. Geez, everything Jane had to say in that post was a matter of record. It’s probably never a good idea to file a “definition of character” suit against a lawyer, especially with a weak case like this. (Yep, I meant “definition.”) I’ll be interested to read what PG has to say about this…he’s had a number of posts about Ellora’s Cave. Maybe she should sue him…he’s a lawyer as well. If you’re going to make a really bad move, might as well double down on it. 😀

  3. As another blogger pointed out, this sets a bad precedent for boutique publishers/small press pubs and bloggers. It brings the idea of LLC-ing my blog back to the forefront of my to-do list, because if Jane can be sued for posting that, I imagine any rabid and angry pub or author could do it to someone for not liking what they’ve written. Like perhaps a poor review.
    A friend of mine was threatened with a lawsuit last year and she simply reviewed a book.

  4. The Authors should be suing to get their rights reverted *now*. If they wait to file, they may be lost to them in a bankruptcy filing.

  5. I am a former EC editor and have not been paid since the beginning of the summer.

  6. Seems to me this isn’t so much an attempt to SLAPP Jane, but to scare authors away from complaining publicly. If that’s the case, then EC may not care one bit whether their case has merit, and are gambling on the mere filing intimidating disgruntled authors into shutting up. I suspect they’ll fail. I’ve already seen several authors today, as a direct result of this filing, pull all EC titles from their own sites and refuse to continue promoting them.

    • * and editors

    • It is 100% an attempt to intimidate bloggers and authors. It’s also an attempt to discover which authors passed Jane info. There’s that little delightful nugget near the end of the complaint where they “ask” for Jane to turn over info on anonymous commenters.

  7. This is going to be entertaining as h***. Jane, aka Jennifer, didn’t report anything that wasn’t already a matter of public record, and she’s a smart cookie. EC just opened themselves up to discovery, which they may have handed not only Jane, but all of their creditors including their authors, the proverbial smoking gun.

    • I don’t know. I’m not a lawyer, and there are all sorts of obscure points of law that might mean it’s not as cut and dry as that. I’m not going to celebrate until the fat lady starts singing.

      • *sigh* If it’s like other lawsuits EC has filed where the defendant fights back, EC won’t show up and the lawsuit gets dismissed. If my OH license was still active, I’d volunteer to help Jane/Jennifer.

        But I’ll keep my popcorn warm just in case.

        • PG agrees with you on the discovery aspect:

          “PG says truth is a defense in a defamation suit. This means that Jane gets to use the discovery phase of the litigation to force Ellora’s Cave to disclose all sorts of information, including information that shows what Jane wrote is true.”

          • Just because I stopped practicing law doesn’t mean I forgot everything. LOL The burden of proof is still on the plaintiff, and they’ll have to produce records showing they paid everyone. That was one of the major sticking points in the EC v. Braeshears case.

  8. AltheGreatandPowerful // 26 September, 2014 at 11:19 pm // Reply

    I posted her a link to Popehat, because Ken White has helped people find lawyers to fight SLAPPs in the past.

  9. Personally I think they should be running into legal problems. Why are they paying lawyers to do this when they’ve gone delinquent on payments owed to their authors?

    Why has their been no lawsuits against Ellora’s Cave…or has there? Something tells me there’ll be one on Monday, maybe a class-action.

  10. I was the target of a defamation action. It was meritless, but it certainly is a hassle.

    The defendant will want to see if Ohio offers relief in the form of an anti-SLAPP law. If so, she could file a motion with the court which forces the the plaintiff to show evidence of defamation, or the suit is dismissed and attorney’s fees are awarded to the defendant.

    Also, keep in mind it’s not defamation if it’s true, or it’s presented as opinion (instead of as fact). Also, if the person bringing the suit can be considered a “public figure” (California courts have held that authors are often “public figures”), then the burden of proof in a defamation action typically rises — the plaintiff has to prove a “reckless disregard” for the truth, not just error.

    Any oneline person who is targeted should immediately go to the Online Digital Media Law Project (http://www.dmlp.org/). That site (a part of the Harvard Berkman Center) contains a wealth of useful information, and also gives you access to the referrals to defamation attorneys, free counseling, and — if you’re income qualified — subsidized attorney’s fees.

    You don’t have to go this alone. So don’t.

  11. Is should be noted that it’s not just authors who EC hasn’t paid. They also owe money to editors and cover artists.

  12. Just as a note, the temporary restraining order would not prevent DA from talking about the lawsuit. The TRO just asks them to take down the blogpost in question.

    They would never be able to get a TRO asking DA not to talk about the lawsuit–not unless DA’s talking about it would so inconceivably bias the jury pool, which is unlikely as this is not a suit that’s of interest to the general reader.

    It’s not generally prudent to talk of pending litigation, though, for a number of reasons, so I doubt we’ll hear much from Jane besides what is made a matter of public record.

  13. I’ve added a post to support EC authors who are leaving the publisher in various ways.

    http://deirdre.net/elloras-cave-author-exodus-support-thread/

    I’m hoping to make it a more complete resource of authors, editors, and cover artists who are (or have been) having issues with EC so that readers, authors who need editors, and authors who need cover artists can turn to them.

  14. Perhaps Jane should take a leaf out of Rachel Nunes book, and start a crowdsourcing campaign to get funds to defend the lawsuit. Rachel Nunes has a link on her site (she is suing someone who allegedly stole her work) http://www.ranunes.com

  15. Will you be named next for republishing the bit characterizing the person’s behavior?

  16. I agree with Suzan Hardan (I have skimmed so others may have stated the same or similar). (I’m not a lawyer, FYI, just work for them!). The burden of proof is on the plaintiff to prove what the defendant wrote/said is untrue. From what I’ve seen of the rantings and goings on emanating from EC, this is a knee-jerk sort of action that will, as many have said, result in exposing a whole lot of what I’m sure the EC folks would rather not be exposed. And the upshot is then that once all of that is out in the bright light of day, it gives ammunition to all the other editors and authors who might decide to use it to pursue their own suits and claims. Additionally, I think that DA’s tempered reporting is just reporting – journalistic style. It’s a bit different for a recognized reporting site like DA to give an overview of a situation, and for a single author to blast an entity or person on their blog. That’s why everyone should be fairly circumspect in what they write, how they say it, as well all the folks who respond.

  17. I’ve already forwarded Jane several emails I sent to the CFO asking about nonpayment, which were never answered by the CFO. I hope they will be placed into evidence.

1 2

13 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Ellora’s Cave Sues Dear Author Book Blog for Defamation | The Passive Voice | A Lawyer's Thoughts on Authors, Self-Publishing and Traditional Publishing
  2. Ellora’s Cave, Dear Author, the Streisand Effect and freedom of speech. | Her Hands, My Hands
  3. Ellora’s Cave Author Exodus Support Thread
  4. Today in disturbing publishing news | angelahighland.com
  5. Links: Saturday, September 27th | Love in the Margins
  6. The Week in Review: September 28, 2014 | The Literary Omnivore
  7. We’re Small Bloggers, but We’re Feeling the Fallout: Ellora’s Cave and the Suit Against Dear Author | Bad Menagerie
  8. Our reply to Ellora’s Cave’s recent actions | The Book Pushers | Book Reviews | Book Chatter
  9. The WTFckery Report: Ellora’s Cave Suing Dear Author Blog for Defamation. Why Book Bloggers Should Be Worried | Babbling About Books, and More!
  10. Ellora’s Cave and Elephants in the Room | Blue night. Black iron. Golden rope.
  11. Update on the Ellora’s Cave v. Dear Author Defamation Suit - The Digital Reader
  12. News For Book Bloggers - Book Blogger News & Info from the Bloggerista
  13. Author's Caught in the Middle while the Streisand Effect Rages - Butterscotch Martini Girls

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*