It’s Official – B&N Has Thrown in the Towel on the Nook

It's Official - B&N Has Thrown in the Towel on the Nook Barnes & Noble

Len Riggio has just dashed the hopes of everyone who had been praying for a Nook turnaround.

According to Publishers Weekly, Riggio told the attendees at the B&N annual meting that the retailer fully recognizes its failures as a tech company.

Riggio also assured shareholders that B&N is no longer in the tech business. While the Nook e-reader and e-books will remain a part of the company's offerings to customers, bricks and mortar stores will be its focus. Riggio explained that when e-book sales began exploding several years ago, B&N felt it had no choice but to enter the digital market. In retrospect, Riggio said, B&N didn't have the culture or financing to compete with the likes of Amazon and Google.

Instead, according to Riggio, B&N will focus on its physical stores and will partner with technology companies to keep a presence in the digital space. "There is no business model in technology" for B&N, Riggio acknowledged.

While I am sure everyone saw this coming, we were all still hoping for a miracle turnaround where someone at B&N got a clue and figured out how to rescue the Nook.

Digital was the one bright light at B&N - it's why B&N revenues rose in 2010 and 2011. Online sales and ebook sales made up for B&N's declining retail sales,  painting the picture that B&N was making an orderly transition to the modern era.

People want to shop online, and they want to buy ebooks, and for a brief while it looked like B&N could give customers what they want. But that illusion was slowly stripped away as Nook entered its death spiral following the 2012 holiday season.

Nook revenues have since declined to the point that Kindle Unlimited is far larger (and the new version of B&N's website is so painful to use that online sales are also declining). While one estimate said  Nook ebooks sales exceeded Kobo ebook sales in 2016, you shouldn't bet money on things staying that way.

Instead, the more likely scenario is that B&N is going to strike a deal with Kobo to let the latter either run Nook or simply take over Nook customer accounts. In either case, B&N will got from being a potential player to being little more than one of Kobo's retail partners - think Indigo, only in the US.

B&N probably winces every time they are compared to Indigo, but that Canadian bookseller is the perfect example of what Barnes & Noble could have done. Both companies got into ebooks in 2009 by launching their own platforms, but Indigo was smart about it: they found international partners early on, and when Rakuten came calling in 2011, Indigo sold out.

Indigo still sells Kobo ebooks and ereaders, but they don't own the platform and thus don't have to invest in or maintain it. Instead they have focused on turning their retail business around (and they've succeeded, too).

Indigo is the perfect example of how to turn around an ailing bookseller.

It's too late for B&N's current management to copy Indigo, but who knows, when B&N goes bankrupt maybe Indigo will get a chance to take over the remains and see if they can pull their magic trick twice.

image by dreig

About Nate Hoffelder (10944 Articles)
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader:"I've been into reading ebooks since forever, but I only got my first ereader in July 2007. Everything quickly spiraled out of control from there. Before I started this blog in January 2010 I covered ebooks, ebook readers, and digital publishing for about 2 years as a part of MobileRead Forums. It's a great community, and being a member is a joy. But I thought I could make something out of how I covered the news for MobileRead, so I started this blog."

24 Comments on It’s Official – B&N Has Thrown in the Towel on the Nook

  1. “Riggio also assured shareholders that B&N is no longer in the tech business.”

    But it never was, not really. Their website has never been useful enough that I’d consider buying a book from it.

    And they still hate taking an order for something they didn’t think to stock.

    I’ve been getting a good chuckle watching SZ whine about how important B&N is to writers and publishers – even though they and B&N itself seem to disagree with him.

  2. It is upsetting and a complete betrayal. When BN came out with their first Ereader they were at the front of the line. How could they ignore their customers and lose so much ground so quickly? They should be ashamed and embarrassed at where they have fallen so low and why. They at least should honor their customers and turn them over to Kobo instead of dragging this embarrassing travesty any further.

  3. Barnes and igNoble doomed themselves when they went along with the “we hate digital” traditional publishers and let Big Book essentially dictate their business model for paper and digital. They bought Fictionwise to have a claim to digital, but totally ignored the way Fictionwise very successfully marketed eBooks, since it didn’t fit Big Book’s “high prices == high profits” business model. I doubt the Big Book publisers are ever going to figure out that destroying a major book chain for a short-term money-and-power grab is the equivalent of cutting their own throats.

    • B&N “doomed themselves” with their own idiocy.

      From letting Amazon run them over in the early days — when Amazon could’ve been squashed like a bug — to torpedoing the Nook with absurd memory constraints to living room lounge chairs in their stores that became a haven for the homeless to an on-line strategy that can charitably be considered stupid, to their latest venture of the restaurant biz, they’ve proven themselves too stupid to remain in business and THAT’S why their stock price has fallen 75% in a few short years.

  4. As I see it, their fundamental problem is, they’re a physical book store chain. They sell print books, and they cannot bring themselves to do ANYTHING that could harm print book sales. Amazon sells tons of stuff in additon to books, and doesn’t care nearly as much whether you buy print or ebook, and in fact since they’re mostly a website, they can appreciate the savings in shipping costs for ebooks.

    Well, this explains why my B&N sales are so much lower than my iBooks sales.

  5. In fact, Indigo IS coming to America in 2018, apparently. After Kobo’s nightmare with Borders, do they REALLY want an association with B&N; soon to become the next Borders? They get — what — 18 months, maybe 2 years of distribution before the get caught up in another bankruptcy? When their pals at Indigo, evidently, will be here within the year? With a website operation all ready to go and better than B&N?

    https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/bookselling/article/74306-canadian-bookseller-indigo-eyes-a-move-into-u-s-for-2018.html

  6. Unlike Amazon, B&N just had to focus on physical and electronic book sales. They did not have to sell tablets, they should have just focused on selling and supporting their eReaders. In addition,they had the advantage of having physical stores that provided customer service.

    Their failure is not due to Amazon; this was just bad leadership.

  7. They’re going to let KOBO run it?
    There goes my income stream. Kobo bans X and lots of kink erotica. I was making bank off of Kobo until they decided that they didn’t want people like me competing with 50 shades of gray (which they sell).
    B&N’s website is the most mismanaged thing out there, and it’s a shame because they make way more than kobo does. I don’t know why they’ve continually hired ASSHOLES to run the website, but sadly, they have.

  8. Barnes and Noble seem to Want to fail. Taking out NEW RELEASE sections, their terrible website, hateful employees who never straighten a magazine, chairs where people “library” all day, coffee shops where people read the magazines for free while B&N return them.

    B&N is a clusterfrack so easily repaired.

  9. B&N made it almost impossible to publish a book on Nook. I looked a couple of years ago and gave up trying to understand exactly what they wanted. On the other hand Amazon made it a process of click, click & done. Which one would you choose? B&N were out of the ebook business in the UK for a year or two.

  10. I am sorry, this does look like a death strike for B&N. I like my nooks, and I love their stores. But, progress happens. If management is shortsighted, or tech-phobic, the store just won’t last. I’m not sure anything will last anymore, tech is growing and taking over most things nowadays. We’ll all be sorry when there aren’t any more stores.

  11. So, focusing on its physical stores and partnering with others for its technology.

    How is this different from what they’ve been doing lately? Sounds like they’re just finally admitting it is all.

  12. It’s sad what happened to B&N. I had received their first Nook as a present and enjoyed using it. Maybe they should do a trial run a new one.

  13. I’ve wondered for years why Barnes & Noble didn’t make their own subscription-based ereading service like Kindle Unlimited, but without exclusivity…

    And why they didn’t leverage the ONE thing they had over Amazon in the bookselling business: physical bookstores. One of the downsides indie authors lament about not going trad pub is not seeing their books in physical bookstores… but what if indie bestsellers made it into print in the B&N physical stores? How many indies would have flocked from KDP Select to try B&N and maybe see their book on the shelf? B&N could have slowed or turned around the slow bleed of indie books out of Nook and into Amazon’s exclusive KDP Select… But if Nook readers can’t find the books they want to read at B&N, what else would happen but them hightailing it to Amazon, where they can get any books they want?

    Was it all just to appease the big traditional publishers? Not like those publishers were going to withhold their books from the largest bookstore chain.

    Unfortunate decisions and sad outcome for what could have been something great…

  14. I love my Nook and had so many high hopes for it. At first I could and did read things from many places on it. Especially old, out of print books – as in Medieval, Victorian and early 20th century. Then the Nook changed so I could no longer read those books. And when my CC expired and was replaced, I suddenly could not read the books purchased on the Nook because they had been purchased with a different CC number. Now I can only easily read Nook purchased books, online items and books saved as txts because of changes to the Nook reading platform. So much for reading anything from the massive number of e-books I purchased at the onset. I still, however, like my Nook tablet. I am not surprised, however, that B&N will no longer support it – they never supported it properly.

  15. Barnes & Noble top management in the last 10 years seems to present a textbook example of ostriches doing everything possible to avoid opportunity. They were a great company who were already in the digital marketplace. They could have hired decent management who understood running a digital biz, and been even more successful. They didn’t have to ‘beat’ Amazon, just hold the course into the future of reading. Instead, they choose to fall back and sell cards and toys. Sigh…

  16. They should just sell out their Nook business to Kobo and let us read our Nook books on Kobo’s excellent devices. BN could have really given Amazon a run for the money but they hired the wrong people and stopped listening to their customers. They put out their latest e-ink reader and did nothing to enhance it to keep up with the competition. If the company isn’t interested in their own product – why should customers be interested in them. You have to give loyalty to receive loyalty and Barnes and Noble is a huge fail.

  17. I have over 1000 Nook ebooks. These are not my physical files to keep and read on other devices. I can’t even import them to another reader. If they stop supporting my ebooks I lose all my library. This is not fair. Please give me my files and let me choose what reader app I want to use to read my books on.

    • I agree with you. I have close to 700 books in my archive library. I hope they do something so we can save these books. We paid good money for these. I don’t know much about the other program they mentioned. Kobo??? Can that by chance open the nook books?

    • If they do the same thing as Kobo did with Sony, you will be notified that you have X amount of days to verify your collection has been transferred. After that date, you won’t be able to access those books and will have to rebuy them. I hope they don’t do what they did with the last couple of models of Sony eReaders where you couldn’t connect the two. I have my Sony ebooks on the Kobo account, but I cannot read them on my eReader unless they were already downloaded onto it.

  18. I thought the original Nook and the Nook Simple Touch were the best ereaders of their time. Nook Color/Tablet and Nook HD/HD+ were excellent as well. Now I’ve switched to Kobo ereaders and regular Android tablets. Their failure in the ebook market is a whole other story.

  19. Kobo sucks. When they took over the Sony bookstore, they never managed to make it user friendly with the last couple of models of the Sony eReader. I still have my Sony, but it mostly is used for free books and library books. Got a Kindle for everything else.

10 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Paul Biba’s eBook, eLibrary, eMuseum and ePublishing news compilation for week ending Friday, September 23 | The Digital Reader
  2. The Nook, she is dead – The Huffington Global
  3. The Nook, she is dead | Breaking & Viral News Feeds from India
  4. The Nook, she is dead | KWOTABLE
  5. The Nook, she is dead – Cryptorawr
  6. The Nook, she is dead |
  7. The Nook, she is dead | the TECH show
  8. The Nook, she is dead | ADMK Agency
  9. The Nook, she is dead - Blog
  10. Episode 182 – Michael Hyatt, Kindle in China, and The Future of Nook | Sell More Books Show

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*