The Role Of Technology In Modern Student Learning

Most classroom technology is meant to support learning, but many teaching tools can distract from learning. If a student has a lab report due tonight, and she has three journal articles open on her computer as well as a buzzing group chat and a paused video lecture at minute 22, then the technology is probably just keeping her busy.
Both. Now that’s an honest answer and definitely deserves more exploration than your typical ‘yes’ or ‘no’ for school.
What Actually Changed In The Classroom
Most of the educational technology in use today is new to schools in the last 10-15 years, but most of the hardware has been around for 20-30 years. What has really changed is the level of access that most students have to a variety of technology tools. For the first time, a student in a rural or under-resourced school can watch a Stanford University lecture, run a complex statistics simulation, and get feedback on their writing within a matter of hours.
Providing all students with equal access to all courses is important to fairness. The U.S. Department of Education notes how technology can provide a wide array of advanced placement, foreign language, and computer programming courses to schools of rural and low income students.
Having access to all of these learning tools does not solve the problem, however. There are many technologies that students and teachers can use in the classroom, but most of them are unknown to most people. The school, therefore, must teach the student how to use these various technologies in the classroom.
Where The Real Gains Happen
Technology has a unique ability to offer experiences that cannot be replicated with books. This is true for many examples of technology.
Practice software adapts to a student’s skill level as he or she works through problems. The software adjusts to better meet the student’s needs if he or she is having difficulty with certain concepts, for example missing a few answers on a set of fraction problems. He or she may see more of those types of problems to practice until he or she demonstrates an understanding of the skill.
Technology for collaborative work enables students to work in groups more effectively. Instead of one student typing up a report while the others sit idly by, all students can work on a single document at the same time. Teachers even get to see a revision history to determine who contributed what to the final product.
The ability to complete virtual lab experiments allows for actions to be taken that in the physical world would cost too much or even be dangerous. Students can for example mix chemicals that would explode in real life, or watch a population crash in 100 years time. They can fail, and then try again.
Technology can enable a lot of learning, but there is also the need for students to be able to use technology for support of learning outside of class time. There are many resources which can be used for structured academic help when needed such as writing help for a coursework deadline for example – a service such as SpeedyPaper could provide some insight to a well-organized and written paper.
The Attention Problem
This is a critical issue that many technology articles fail to recognize: that the same technology which brings knowledge also brings distractions.
Studies have shown that it can take longer than 20 minutes to come back to focus after an interruption. Many students have notifications turned on for their devices and are studying in fragments of time throughout the hour. They are not studying for an hour, they are studying in short bursts of time throughout the hour.
And, yes, some students manage their digital lives well. They read their material, complete their work, and close down their computers after a long study session. Others appear to be studying for hours but fail to absorb any of the material. Not until grades are posted does the student realize that all that time was squandered because of interruptions.
By removing yourself from the stream of other things you could be doing for one study session, you’ll be surprised at how much more you complete!
Skills Technology Can’t Teach For You
Technology can deliver information but not wisdom, however. Digital tools are especially poor at helping students learn to make judgments.
As for research, it can be deluged in a matter of seconds by a search engine. The rest is up to human judgment. We have noted before that Stanford History Education Group (SHEG) studies on this topic have found that even very smart students struggle to evaluate online sources. They tend to trust sites that are polished-looking rather than plain but accurate.
Thus, teachers must use technology as a facilitation tool, and one of the most important things they can teach their students about technology is how to use it critically. In terms of research on the Internet, for example, students must be able to determine who wrote a site, when it was written, and what the author’s purpose is in publishing it on the Web.
On the other hand, there are many aspects of academic work which technology cannot replace. For example, using spell-check and grammar-check functions can aid in locating and correcting errors in writing. However, these programs have the capability to only inform the writer of mistakes found by the program, and therefore cannot inform the writer whether or not an argument is developed effectively throughout a paper. This is why resources, such as the Purdue OWL (Online Writing Laboratory), exist to explain and provide examples of effective writing practices, including methods of organizing and developing written work, proper methods of citation, and methods of revising for content as well as for form.
What Teachers And Students Get Wrong
There are a number of mistakes that are typical for technology adoption. The most common ones are listed here.
- New apps are often viewed as strategies in of themselves and therefore are not sufficient to support learning on their own.
- Teachers are given a platform on Monday but expected to use it effectively by Tuesday after having received no training.
- Using technology in place of discussion to supplement learning.
- Disregarding students without home access to the Internet or suitable study areas.
A homework assignment with video content also assumes that students have a quiet place to do their work and access to fast wifi at home. The reality for many households is that students do not have access to either.
A Practical Way To Use It Well
Remember that just because there are many tools does not mean you need to use them all. Find a few that you can incorporate into your teaching and have your students use in their studies on a regular basis.
- Use one note taking system throughout the academic term.
- Use a calendar to list all of the deadlines from your syllabus as soon as you receive it.
- Turn off notifications during study blocks.
- Test yourself with flashcards or practice quizzes instead of rereading.
- Verify all online sources against at least one reliable secondary source.
Simple. Good study habits are for the most part dull and technology should be used to enhance them rather than to replace them.
Looking Ahead
We are now waiting to see what types of guidance the U.S. Department of Education and UNESCO will offer in terms of basic rules to follow with new technologies, in addition to what schools are already doing. I know many teachers are already aware of the many ways students are using Artificial Intelligence to complete homework, but I also know that many are choosing to ignore the reality of students’ use of these technologies.
What is the smartest school doing with AI? They are framing a different question than allowing AI in their learning environment. They are deciding what skills they want their students to be able to learn by themselves in their learning environment and creating assignments to help them learn those skills.
Innovative technology should be used to enhance learning rather to appear ‘cool’ and enabling students to gain more knowledge and to understand concepts better than before.
Going back to the biology student who is working late at night and completing the online lecture material, closing all of her other tabs, and writing her own report on the laptop. The laptop did its job as a tool. The habits of the student are more important than the technology.