No, WHSmith Didn’t Add DRM to Cory Doctorow’s eBooks

No, WHSmith Didn't Add DRM to Cory Doctorow's eBooks DeBunking
Click to embiggen

Did you catch the kerfluffle yesterday? In a story covered on TeleRead (and elsewhere) an indie author named Simon Royle accused the UK bookseller WHSmith of adding DRM to his ebooks:

DRM had, without my knowledge, been added to my book. I quickly checked my other books; same thing. Then I checked the books of authors who, because of their vocal and public opposition, I know are against DRM – Konrath, Howey, and Doctorow, to name a few – same result. ALL books on WHSmith have DRM in them.

...

At this time I don’t know who is putting the DRM in the books, but I strongly suspect it is WHSmith.

If you haven't heard about this yet then I'd suggest you ignore the story.

The claim that WHSmith added DRM is baseless because one, it's technically impossible for the bookseller to decide to add DRM, two, no one who reported on the story bothered to buy an ebook and verify that it had DRM, and three, this turned out to be a website bug.

First of all, this claim makes about as much sense as whining about WHSmith putting an ugly book cover on a paper book. It is about that ridiculous.

WHSmith can't make any decisions about DRM because they don't handle that end of the ebook transaction. This bookseller is a partner to Kobo. When it comes to ebooks Kobo is the one that is actually handling all the back end technical stuff, not WHSmith.

Second, this attack on WHSmith reminds me of the Lendink lynch mob. Last August a bunch of authors freaked out and made a baseless accusation that a legit ebook lending site was pirating their ebooks, only they forgot to confirm that Lendink was indeed pirating their ebooks.

I am bringing that up again because the author who posted the original complaint never bother to confirm his allegations by buying one of his ebooks. If he had bought an ebook and downloaded it he would likely have discovered that the ebook did not have DRM.

I can't buy his ebooks and confirm the lack of DRM because WHSmith won't sell to me, but I would bet that I am correct. This issue has been confirmed as a website bug by Kobo.

Curiously enough, this bug has not been corrected, but the website has been updated in response to the kerfluffle yesterday. If you go check that author's ebooks on the WHSmith website then you will see that they no longer are listed as having DRM. The same goes for Cory Doctorow's ebooks.

While that might sound like the problem has been fixed I'm pretty sure that WHSmith swapped one label for another.

In any case, I refuse to believe any part of this story without proof. There's this thing called evidence, and so far no one has presented any.

Nate Hoffelder

View posts by Nate Hoffelder
Nate Hoffelder is the founder and editor of The Digital Reader: He's here to chew bubble gum and fix broken websites, and he is all out of bubble gum. He has been blogging about indie authors since 2010 while learning new tech skills at the drop of a hat. He fixes author sites, and shares what he learns on The Digital Reader's blog. In his spare time, he fosters dogs for A Forever Home, a local rescue group.

3 Comments

  1. Brian21 March, 2013

    Bug and Kobo, two words that always seem to go together. 😉

    Reply
  2. Greg M.21 March, 2013

    Can we call the anti-DRM crew reactionary yet?

    Reply
    1. Thomas22 March, 2013

      Yes. The notion that one can own what one buys is an old-fashioned idea. It has no place in a world where corporation are legally people.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to top