Spain Passes the Google Tax, And Makes Other Terrible Changes to Copyright Law
A new amendment to Spanish copyright law passed the upper house of Spain’s Cortes Generales today, and it is due to become law next year. El Pais reports that the amendment makes a number of revisions to existing law, including the creation of a controversial tax on news aggregators.
The new law makes many problematic changes, including requiring universities to pay fees to a collection society for digital course materials which had otherwise been released under a CC license, but the one I am most interested in today is the tax on news aggregators. (You can find a complete breakdown on the changes on Google en Espanol.)
Colloquially known as the Google tax, the new law is intended to force Google as well as other search engines and news aggregators to pay for the use of links to news articles published elsewhere.
But it probably won’t work – at least not with Google.
The text of the changes to Spanish copyright law (PDF) is difficult to understand, but Spanish news sources say that it is actually worse than previously expected.
The law gives copyright holders the inalienable right to be paid for the use of their work – including a link. This means that they can’t decide to give away the content for free, something Google has required in Germany and elsewhere.
TBH, I’m not sure myself that the law says that links must be licensed, but the text of the law (PDF) is convoluted enough that I am not comfortable arguing with a native speaker.
On the plus side there is an exception for excerpts used for news and entertainment purposes, which means sites like this blog are safe (social networks might also be covered), but the law is still going to compel aggregators like Reddit, Google News, and Spain’s own Menéame to pay for the use of links.
And just so we’re clear, one of the core concepts of the internet, the web link, is now considered to be copyright infringement in Spain when used by certain parties.
Please excuse while I go roll a SAN check.
It’s not clear where news sites and aggregators in Spain will be going from here, but I do know that Google has already issued a statement (originally in Spanish):
We are disappointed with the new law because we believe that services like Google News help publishers to drive traffic to their websites. As regards to the future, we will continue working with Spanish publishers to help them increase their income while we consider our options under the new regulation.
Google hasn’t said how they will respond to the changes in the law but I would bet that at a minimum Google will be delisting any site that might be covered by the new provisions. The search engine giant has taken similar steps in the past, including in Belgium and Germany, when other publishers tried to force it to pay for the free advertising it sends them.
There’s even a chance that Google might pull out of Spain entirely, but at this point that is just wild speculation.
All I know for sure today is that most if not all of the publishers who pushed for this Google tax will come to regret it in short order. It is safe to say that these sites rely on Google for anywhere between a quarter and half of their site traffic, and with Google no longer sending visitors their way the drop in traffic will quickly be felt in the pocketbook.
To be fair, some of the publishers may have already adapted their business model to depend on other sources. The UK’s Telegraph, for example, boosted their site traffic by 20% in June by focusing on better promoting on Facebook.
I do not know that any of the Spanish publishers who backed the Google tax will be able to make similar boasts, though.
image by Tax Credits, efile989
Ana October 30, 2014 um 6:36 pm
" TBH, I’m not sure myself that the law says that links must be licensed, but the text of the law is convoluted enough that I am not comfortable arguing with a native speaker."
Neither a native speaker is going to be comfortable arguing… I’m not a lawyer, so any legal language sounds like jargon to me, but from what I’ve read in some blogs, it’s ambiguous and open to different interpretations, so nobody still knows how they pretend to enforce it and to what extent. Just another piece of trash from our dear politicians, pressured by the traditional press.
Nate Hoffelder October 30, 2014 um 10:59 pm
Bill Collins October 31, 2014 um 8:34 am
Google should just delist the country and then bill their government the cost of the tax if they wish to be relisted. These countries' governments are really acting like thugs these days when it comes to things they don’t understand very well.
Greg Strandberg October 31, 2014 um 11:26 am
Google should get used to it; Europe won’t take monopolies like the US will. And where are all these lawsuits from business owners who’ve lost business because of Google and their menagerie of animals?
Here in the US if someone does something to hurt my business that could cause a problem. Wait until lawyers figure that out, or smell the money, whichever happens first.
The ‘EU Google Tax’ – A very unpromising work in progress? – The Public Privacy November 3, 2014 um 8:38 am
[…] against our best expectations, that it is not the case. Spain has just approved a new copyright law, which is polemic at many levels, namely because it has created a brand new ‘inalienable right’ […]
Uba Babs November 12, 2014 um 8:00 am
Google should take a decisive measure in their approach this issue so as to settle the differences amicably.
Google Goes Nuclear, Shuts Down Google News in Spain ⋆ The Digital Reader December 11, 2014 um 11:23 am
[…] new laws, which were passed at the end of October and will take effect next month, grants publishers the inalienable right to be paid for the use of […]
Spanish Newspapers Beg Gov't To Stop Google News Shutting Down, Ed Minister Says No ⋆ The Digital Reader December 14, 2014 um 1:42 pm
[…] new right for copyright holders out of thin air. The new law will take effect in January and give news publishers the inalienable right to be compensated for the use of snippets and […]
Google News Shutdown in Spain Not Having Much of an Impact ⋆ Ink, Bits, & Pixels March 18, 2015 um 11:19 am
[…] Spain passed its new copyright laws last October, many feared that the license fees imposed on snippets would imperil aggregators like Google News, […]
Germany Wants to Violate the Berne Convention By Limiting Snippets to Seven Words or Fewer | The Digital Reader February 19, 2016 um 11:18 am
[…] used to think Spain and its inalienable right to link licensing was the height of copyright maximalism lunacy, but Germany has raised the […]